Since 1923 • For a greater Loyola

The Maroon

Since 1923 • For a greater Loyola

The Maroon

Since 1923 • For a greater Loyola

The Maroon

Archdiocese of New Orleans releases clergy report regarding sex abuse

Statue+of+Jesus+stands+in+front+of+Marquette+Hall+on+St.+Charles+Ave.+Photo+credit%3A+Jacob+Meyer
Jacob Meyer
Statue of Jesus stands in front of Marquette Hall on St. Charles Ave. Photo credit: Jacob Meyer

On Nov. 2 2018, Archbishop Gregory Aymond released a pastoral letter regarding clergy sex abuse within the Archdiocese of New Orleans.

Along with the letter, Aymond released a list of “the names of Archdiocesan clergy (priests and deacons) who have been removed from ministry for an allegation of sexual abuse of a minor.”

Aymond said that he felt the list was a step forward towards healing within the city.

“I believe it is the right thing to do in order to foster the healing of victims, in a spirit of transparency, and in the pursuit of justice. Jesus reminds us, “The truth will set you free” (John 8:32),” he said.

A staff of more than 10 people, which also included outside legal staff, reviewed the filed of the 2,432 priests that has served in the Archdiocese since 1950. The list includes 57 clergymen that have been accused of sexual abuse.

“We have done our very best to make this report as accurate and complete as possible. If anyone wishes to raise a question about someone not on the list, I invite you to come forward,” Aymond said. “For our sins of the past, we ask for your forgiveness and the mercy of God. Our sin is public and it calls us as church leaders to repentance in order that our church can experience renewal.”

Below is the full 2018 Clergy Report Regarding Abuse list.

The names of Archdiocese of New Orleans clergy who are alive and have been accused of sexually abusing a minor which led to their removal from ministry. In each case, the cleric remains out of ministry.

GEORGE BRIGNAC (DEACON)

Date of Birth: 1935

Ordination: 1976

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1970s; early 1980s

Allegation Received: 1977

Removed from Ministry: 1988

Pastoral Assignments

  • Cabrini High School, New Orleans
  • Our Lady of the Rosary, New Orleans
  • St. Frances Cabrini School, New Orleans
  • St. Louise de Marillac School, Arabi
  • St. Matthew the Apostle School, River Ridge

MICHAEL FARINO

Date of Birth: 1942

Ordination: 1969

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1970s and 1980s

Allegation Received: 1990

Removed from Ministry: 1990

Pastoral Assignments

  • Our Lady of Prompt Succor, Chalmette
  • St. Benilde, Metairie
  • St. Maurice, New Orleans

THOMAS GASPARD GLASGOW

Date of Birth: 1938

Ordination: 1969

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1970s

Allegation Received: 2007

Removed from Ministry: 2008

Pastoral Assignments

  • Mater Dolorosa, New Orleans
  • St. Brigid, New Orleans
  • St. Gabriel, New Orleans
  • St. James Major, New Orleans
  • St. John the Baptist, Edgard
  • St. Philip the Apostle, New Orleans
  • St. Simon Peter, New Orleans

PAUL CALAMARI

Date of Birth: 1944

Ordination: 1980

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1970s

Allegation Received: 2003

Removed from Ministry: 2003

Pastoral Assignments

  • Our Lady of Perpetual Help, Belle Chasse
  • Our Lady of the Rosary, New Orleans, in residence
  • St. Stanislaus School, Bay St. Louis, MS
  • St. Raphael, New Orleans
  • St. Rita, New Orleans, in residence
  • Holy Cross Church, Dover, DE
  • St. Mary of the Assumption, Hockenin, DE
  • St. Peter the Apostle, New Castle, DE

MICHAEL FRASER

Date of Birth: 1949

Ordination: 1975

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1980s; 1990s

Allegation Received: 1998

Removed from Ministry: 2004

Pastoral Assignments

  • Sts. Peter and Paul, Pearl River
  • St. Raphael the Archangel, New Orleans
  • St. Rita Church, New Orleans
  • The Visitation of Our Lady, Marrero

LAWRENCE HECKER

Date of Birth: 1931

Ordination: 1958

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1960s; 1970s

Allegation Received: 1996

Removed from Ministry: 2002

Pastoral Assignments

  • Christ the King, Terrytown
  • Holy Family, Luling
  • Holy Rosary, New Orleans
  • Our Lady of Lourdes, New Orleans
  • St. Anthony, Luling
  • St. Bernadette, Houma
  • St. Charles Borromeo, in residence
  • St. Frances Cabrini, New Orleans
  • St. Francis Xavier, Metairie
  • St. Joseph, Gretna
  • St. Louise de Marillac, Arabi
  • St. Mary, New Roads
  • St. Theresa of Child Jesus, New Orleans

GERARD HOWELL

Date of Birth: 1939

Ordination: 1964

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1960s; 1970s

Allegation Received: 1978

Removed from Ministry: 1980

Pastoral Assignments

  • Holy Trinity, New Orleans
  • Mater Dolorosa, New Orleans
  • Our Lady of Prompt Succor, Westwego
  • Prince of Peace, Chalmette
  • St. Gerard, New Orleans
  • St. Henry, New Orleans
  • St. Lawrence the Martyr, Kenner
  • Sts. Peter and Paul, New Orleans
  • St. Pius X, Baton Rouge

JAMES KILGOUR

Date of Birth: 1946

Ordination: 1982

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1980s

Allegation Received: 1987

Removed from Ministry: 1988

Pastoral Assignments

  • St. Pius X, New Orleans

JAMES LOCKWOOD (DEACON)

Date of Birth: 1933

Ordination: 1974

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1970s

Allegation Received: 1978

Removed from Ministry: 1978

Pastoral Assignments

  • Center of Jesus the Lord, New Orleans
  • Our Lady of Prompt Succor, Chalmette

PATRICK KEANE

Date of Birth: 1948

Ordination: 1973

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1980s

Allegation Received: 1994

Removed from Ministry: 1995

Pastoral Assignments

  • Holy Family, Luling
  • St. Anselm, Madisonville
  • St. Catherine of Siena, Metairie
  • St. Cecilia, New Orleans
  • St. Edward the Confessor, Metairie
  • St. Mary Magdalen, Metairie

GERARD KINANE

Date of Birth: 1945

Ordination: 1973

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1970s; 1980s

Allegation Received: 1993

Removed from Ministry: 2004

Pastoral Assignments

  • Our Lady of the Isle, Grand Isle
  • St. Cecilia, New Orleans, in residence
  • St. Edward the Confessor, Metairie
  • St. Gabriel the Archangel, New Orleans
  • St. Henry, New Orleans
  • St. Hilary, Matthews
  • St. Luke the Evangelist, Slidell, in residence
  • St. Mark, Chalmette
  • St. Mary’s Nativity, Raceland
  • Assumption Catholic Church, Jacksonville, FL
  • Mother Seton Catholic Church, Palm Springs, FL
  • St. John Catholic Church, Atlanta Beach, FL
  • St. Bernadette Church, Canadensis, PA

GERALD PRINZ

Date of Birth: 1939

Ordination: 1968

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1970s

Incardinated Diocese of Houma-Thibodaux: 1977

Allegation Received: 1995

Resigned from Priesthood: 1990

Pastoral Assignments

  • St. Frances de Sales, Houma
  • St. Gregory Barbarigo, Houma

PATRICK SANDERS

Date of Birth: 1963

Ordination: 1990

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1990s

Allegation Received: 2004

Removed from Ministry: 2005

Pastoral Assignments

  • Our Lady of Perpetual Help, Belle Chasse
  • Resurrection of Our Lord, New Orleans
  • St. Angela Merici, Metairie
  • St. Frances Xavier Cabrini, New Orleans
  • St. Peter, Reserve
  • St. Thomas, Pointe-a-la-Hache

JOHN SAX

Date of Birth: 1948

Ordination: 1973

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1980s

Allegation Received: 2000

Removed from Ministry: 2004

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Resurrection, New Orleans
  • St. Cecilia Church, New Orleans
  • St. Clement of Rome, Metairie
  • St. Francis of Assisi, New Orleans, in residence
  • St. Gabriel the Archangel, New Orleans
  • St. Jerome Church, Kenner
  • St. John of the Cross, in residence
  • St. Louis Cathedral, New Orleans
  • St. Peter, Reserve
  • St. Raphael, New Orleans
  • St. Rita, New Orleans, in residence


The names of Archdiocese of New Orleans clergy who are deceased and who admitted or have been publicly accused of sexually abusing a minor.

JOHN BASTY

Date of Birth: 1882

Date of Ordination: 1908

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1940s

Allegation Received: 1946

Date of Death: 1956

Pastoral Assignments:

  • St. Augustine, New Orleans
  • St. Charles Borromeo, Destrehan
  • Sts. Peter and Paul, New Orleans
  • St. Vincent de Paul, New Orleans

PIERRE CELESTIN CAMBIAIRE

Date of Birth: 1871

Ordination: 1898

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1910s

Allegation Received: 1917

Removed from Ministry: 1917

Date of Death: 1955

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Sacred Heart of Jesus, Cameron
  • St. George, Baton Rouge
  • St. Joseph, Grosse-Tete
  • St. Leon, Leonville

CARL DAVIDSON

Date of Birth: 1940

Ordination: 1964

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: early 1980s

Allegation Received: 1989

Removed from Ministry: 2002

Date of Death: 2007

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Annunciation, New Orleans
  • St. James Major, New Orleans
  • St. John Prep, New Orleans
  • St. Raphael the Archangel, New Orleans
  • St. Theresa of the Child Jesus, New Orleans

JAMES BENEDICT

Date of Birth: 1913

Date of Ordination: 1939

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: Late 1950s

Allegation Received: 2003

Date of Death: 1984

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Mater Dolorosa Church, New Orleans
  • Our Lady of Lourdes, New Orleans
  • St. Augustine Church, New Orleans
  • St. Henry Church, New Orleans
  • Ursuline Convent and Academy

DINO CINEL

Date of Birth: 1941

Ordination: 1966

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1980s

Allegation Received: 1988

Removed from Ministry: 1988

Date of Death: 2018

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Professor at Tulane University
  • St. Rita, New Orleans in residence

VINCENT FEEHAN

Date of Birth: 1945

Ordination: 1977

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1970s; early 1980s

Allegation Received: 1987

Voluntary leave of absence: 1987

Date of Death: 2010

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Our Lady of Perpetual Help, Belle Chasse
  • St. Anselm, Madisonville
  • St. Catherine of Siena, Metairie
  • St. Frances Xavier Cabrini, New Orleans

JOHN FRANKLIN

A Priest of the Diocese of Savannah, GA

Serving at the Archdiocese of New Orleans

Date of Birth: 1925

Ordination: 1956

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1950s

Allegation Received: 1959

Removed from Ministry: 1959

Date of Death: unknown

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Ascension, Donaldsonville
  • St. Gabriel, New Orleans

MICHAEL HURLEY

Date of Birth: 1915

Ordination: 1943

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1940s

Allegation Received: 1945

Left Archdiocese: 1955

Date of Death: 2005

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Immaculate Conception Church, Marrero
  • St. Agnes, Baton Rouge
  • St. Francis de Sales, Houma
  • St. Maurice, New Orleans
  • Sts. Peter and Paul, New Orleans

WESLEY MICHAEL LANDRY

Date of Birth: 1923

Ordination: 1948

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1950s

Allegation Received: 1993

Retired from Ministry: 1993

Date of Death: 2002

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Christ the King, Gretna
  • Incarnate Word, New Orleans
  • St. Anthony, Gretna
  • St. Cecilia, New Orleans
  • St. Gabriel the Archangel, New Orleans
  • St. Joseph, Thibodaux
  • St. Leo the Great, New Orleans
  • St. Theresa of the Child Jesus, New Orleans

HOWARD HOTARD

Date of Birth: 1926

Ordination: 1955

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: early 1980s

Allegation Received: 1995

Removed from Ministry: 2002

Date of Death: 2013

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Our Lady of Lourdes, Slidell
  • Sacred Heart Church, Lacombe
  • St. Catherine of Siena, Metairie
  • St. Charles Borromeo, Destrehan
  • St. Mary Pamela, Raceland
  • St. Matthias, New Orleans

JAMES KIRCHER

A Priest of the Diocese of Jackson, MS

In Residence at the Archdiocese of New Orleans

Date of Birth: 1931

Ordination: 1963

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1970s

Allegation Received: 2010

Removed from Ministry: 1991

Date of Death: 2007

In Residence: 1970s

Pastoral Assignments:

  • St. Julian Eymard, Algiers

RALPH LAWRENCE

Date of Birth: 1890

Ordination: 1916

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: early 1930s

Allegation Received: 1935

Leave of absence: 1935

Date of Death: 1992

Pastoral Assignments

  • Mater Dolorosa, New Orleans
  • Our Lady of Good Harbor, Buras
  • Our Lady of Lourdes, Winnfield
  • Sacred Heart Church, Rayville
  • St. Anthony, Baton Rouge

GORHAM JOSEPH PUTNAM

Date of Birth: 1929

Ordination: 1955

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: early 1950s

Allegation Received: 2002

Date of Death: 1993

Pastoral Assignments

  • St. Agnes, Jefferson
  • St. Andrew the Apostle, New Orleans
  • St. Francis de Sales, New Orleans
  • St. John the Baptist, Edgard
  • St. Rita Church, New Orleans

JOHN SEERY

Date of Birth: 1953

Ordination: 1976

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1970s

Allegation Received: 1978

Left the USA: 1978

Date of Death: 2011

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Our Lady of Prompt Succor, Westwego

JOHN THOMANN

Date of Birth: 1930

Ordination: 1958

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1960s

Allegation Received: 1966

Removed from Ministry: 1967

Date of Death: 1989

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Our Lady of Lourdes, New Orleans
  • Our Lady of Prompt Succor, Chackbay
  • Resurrection of Our Lord, New Orleans
  • St. Charles Borromeo Church, Destrehan
  • St. Frances Cabrini, New Orleans
  • St. Henry, New Orleans
  • St. Joseph Church, Gretna
  • St. Joseph, Galliano
  • St. Leo the Great, New Orleans
  • St. Rose of Lima Church, New Orleans

BERNARD SCHMALTZ

Date of Birth: 1947

Ordination: 1973

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1970s

Allegation Received: 1993

Removed from Ministry: 1993

Date of Death: 2010

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Anunziata, Houma
  • St. Clement of Rome
  • St. Francis Xavier, Metairie
  • St. Gabriel the Archangel, New Orleans
  • St. Rose of Lima, New Orleans, in residence

MALCOLM STRASSEL

Date of Birth: 1908

Ordination: 1934

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1960s; early 1970s

Allegation Received: 2006

Date of Death: 1987

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Holy Rosary Church, St. Amant
  • Our Lady of Lourdes, New Orleans
  • Sacred Heart, LaCombe
  • St. Agnes, Baton Rouge
  • St. Charles Borromeo, Destrehan
  • St. Joseph, Gretna
  • St. Mary Pamela, Raceland

JOHN WEBER

Date of Birth: 1919

Ordination: 1945

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1940s

Incardinated into Diocese of Baton Rouge: 1961

Allegation Received: 2005

Date of Death: 2000

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Assumption Parish, Plattenville
  • Holy Trinity, New Orleans
  • St. Ann, Morganza
  • St. Eloi, Theriot
  • St. Rita, New Orleans


The names of religious order priests who were serving in the Archdiocese of New Orleans at the time of the allegation and the archdiocese was notified of the allegation. The investigation and final disposition of the allegation was the responsibility of the religious order.

PAUL AVALLONE, S.D.B.

Date of Birth: 1921

Date of Ordination: 1950

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1950s, early 1960s

Notification from Religious Order: 2011

Date of Death: 2008

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Archbishop Shaw High School
  • Hope Haven, Marrero

PATRICK BRADY, O.P.

Date of Birth: unknown

Ordination: unknown

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1960s; 1970s

Allegation Received: 2002

Date of Death: 1999

Pastoral Assignments:

  • St. Anthony of Padua, New Orleans

STANISLAUS CEGLAR, S.D.B.

Date of Birth: unknown

Ordination: unknown

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1960s

Allegation Received: 2010

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Hope Haven, Marrero

PAUL CSIK, S.D.B.

Date of Birth: 1898

Date of Ordination: unknown

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1960s

Allegation Received: 2010

Date of Death: 1970

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Hope Haven, Marrero

CLAUDE BOUDREAUX, S.J.

Date of Birth: 1925

Date of Ordination: 1955

Notification from Religious Order: 2005

Date of Death: 2016

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Jesuit High School, New Orleans

CORNELIUS CARR, S.J.

Date of Birth: 1920

Ordination: 1951

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1970s; early 1980s

Notification via Media Reports: 2018

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Jesuit High School, New Orleans

JAMES COLLERY, C.S.Sp

Date of Birth: 1920

Ordination: 1948

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: early 1980s

Allegation Received: 2013

Date of Death: 1987

Pastoral Assignments:

  • St. Ann, Metairie

JEROME DUCOTE, O.S.B.

Date of Birth: 1929

Ordination: 1954

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: early 1960s

Allegation Received: 2002

Date of Death: 2006

Pastoral Assignments:

  • St. Joseph Abbey, St. Benedict

ANTHONY ESPOSITO, S.D.B.

Date of Birth: unknown

Ordination: unknown

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1950s; 1960s

Allegation Received: 2006

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Hope Haven, Marrero

JUSTIN FALER, O.S.B.

Date of Birth: 1919

Ordination: 1945

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1950s

Allegation Received: 2002

Date of Death: 1979

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Annunciation, Bogalusa
  • St. Benedict, St. Benedict
  • St. Christopher, Metairie
  • St. Jane de Chantal, Abita Springs
  • St. Joseph Abbey

ANDREW MASTERS, S.V.D.

Date of Birth: unknown

Ordination: unknown

Allegation Received: 1993

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Our Lady of Perpetual Help, Belle Chasse
  • St. Augustine, New Orleans

JOSEPH PANKOWSKI, S.D.B.

Date of Birth: 1915

Ordination: unknown

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1940s; 1950s

Allegation Received: 2006

Deceased 1981

Pastoral Assignments

  • Hope Haven, Marrero

ALFRED PIMPLE, O.F.M.

Date of Birth: 1911

Ordination: 1938

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1950s

Allegation Received: 1959

Date of Death: 1983

Pastoral Assignments:

  • St. Mary of the Angels, New Orleans
  • St. Patrick, Port Sulphur

ERNEST FAGIONE, S.D.B.

Date of Birth: 1917

Ordination: 1947

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1950s; 1960s

Allegation Received: 2006

Date of Death: 2006

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Archbishop Shaw High School
  • Hope Haven, Marrero
  • St. John Bosco, Harvey

AUGUST KITA, S.D.B.

Date of Birth: 1931

Ordination: 1960

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1960s; 1970s

Allegation Received: 2006

Date of Death: 2008

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Hope Haven, Marrero

WILLIAM MILLER, C.Ss.R.

Date of Birth: 1896

Ordination: 1922

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1940s

Allegation Received: 1946

Date of Death: 1972

Pastoral Assignments:

  • St. Alphonsus, New Orleans

DONALD PEARCE S.J.

Date of Birth: 1925

Ordination: 1959

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1960s

Allegation Received: 2003

Notification from Religious Order: 2010

Date of Death: 2016

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Jesuit High School, New Orleans

ALFRED SOKOL, S.D.B.

Date of Birth: 1911

Ordination: unknown

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: 1960s; 1970s

Allegation Received: 2006

Deceased 2004

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Hope Haven, Marrero

ROGER TEMME, O.M.I.

Date of Birth: 1947

Ordination: 1976

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1970s

Allegation Received: 1995

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Ave Maria Retreat House, Lafitte
  • Our Lady of Guadalupe, New Orleans

BENJAMIN WREN, S.J.

Date of Birth: 1931

Ordination: 1961

Estimated Timeframe of Abuse: late 1970s; early 1980s

Allegation Received: 2016

Date of Death: 2006

Pastoral Assignments

  • Community of John the Evangelist, New Orleans
  • Loyola University, New Orleans

The following religious order priests were taken out of ministry by the Archbishop of New Orleans in 2002, even though the abuse was not alleged to have occurred in the Archdiocese of New Orleans.

CHARLES COYLE, S.J.

Date of Birth: 1932

Ordination: 1965

Date of Death: 2015

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Center for Jesus the Lord, New Orleans
  • Holy Cross High School, New Orleans
  • Jesuit High School, New Orleans
  • St. Andrew the Apostle Church, Algiers
  • St. Cecilia Parish (in residence)
  • St. Louise de Marillac, Arabi
  • St. Raphael, New Orleans

BERNARD KNOTH, S.J.

Date of Birth: 1949

Ordination: 1977

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Loyola University

BRYAN FONTENOT, O.P.

Date of Birth: 1953

Ordination: 1981

Pastoral Assignments

  • Xavier University, New Orleans

JOSEPH PELLETTIERI, C.Ss.R.

Date of Birth: 1939

Ordination: 1965

Date of Death: 2018

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Ave Maria Retreat House, Crown Point

C. RICHARD NOWERY, C.S.C.

Date of Birth: 1938

Ordination: 1968 Date of Death: 2018

Pastoral Assignments:

  • Sacred Heart of Jesus, New Orleans

Leave a Comment
More to Discover
About the Contributors
Andres Fuentes, Staff Writer
Andres Fuentes is in his first year at Loyola and serves as Sports Editor for The Maroon. He has previously served as Assistant Sports Editor. As a native of New Orleans, he enjoys going to many of the city sites when he isn't watching his favorite sports teams. Contact: [email protected] or @af_nola
Jacob Meyer, Staff Photographer
Jacob  is a Junior at Loyola as a Digital Filmmaking Major.  He serves as the Content Producer at the Maroon, in which he serves as a liason between the Photography Desk and the Newsroom, Maroon Minute, and Social Media of The Maroon, and is afforded significant creative and artistic direction for new photography training and projects at The Maroon. Jacob has worked as a freelance photographer and cinematographer specializing in Live Music before he joined The Maroon, and has worked with many Loyola students and notable personalities such as Big Freedia and Regis Prograis. Contact: [email protected]

Comments (0)

All The Maroon Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *